Perfection (Part 2); Reverence of Excellence
Friday, June 11, 2010 at 04:57AM Once we have a clear understanding of perfection and excellence -- that perfection is an ideal and excellence is an actual result -- the next step is to make perfection the goal in all things, big and small.
“Practice does not make perfect. Only perfect practice makes perfect.” --Vince Lombardi
Perfection? Isn’t that a contradiction since we can never reach an ideal? Not at all. Just consider the alternative: How can excellence be the central goal?
Having “excellence” as a goal would be like driving a golf ball onto a green without a pin. What part of the green would be deemed to be most excellent? To where would we putt once there? How would we know if we were even on the right green?
Greens without a Pin-- To where do we drive?
Rather, excellence is the measure of our proximity to perfection; to the ideal, or to the pin. Indeed, without the benchmark of perfection, excellence is unmeasurable, unknowable, and unobtainable.

"Perfection is not attainable, but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence." -- Vince Lombardi
Yet, there are many who suggest the pursuit of perfection is pure folly. Here’s but a sampling of quotes you can Google:
- “Perfection is the enemy of success”
- “It is impossible to reach “perfection”, so striving for perfection is foolish.”
- “The mindset of a person focused on perfection is critical, harried, time-crunched, unable to see the big picture, stressed, unconfident, and rarely allowed any sense of true accomplishment and personal reward”
- "Perfection is not attainable, and chasing it is pointless.”
- “The striving for perfection is the striving for the illusive “one right way,” making others wrong or inferior.”
- “When you strive for perfection, you shoot yourself in the foot right from the start. You’ve given yourself a goal that’s unreachable...Perfection holds you back from reaching your true potential.”
- “I don’t believe God wants us to strive for perfection because he knows that will not happen. No one is perfect.”
- "I am careful not to confuse excellence with perfection. Excellence, I can reach for; Perfection is God's business"
- “There are many people in the world who struggle with letting go of perfection. I was one of those people and when I finally learned to give it up I felt as though a 10 ton brick had been lifted off my shoulders.”
- "Am I guilty of teaching perfection instead of striving for excellence? In the first place, am I clear with how these two words actually mean? "
Then there is this well-known rant entitled “Excellence vs. Perfection,” that trashes all things perfection:
Excellence vs. Perfection
Perfection is being right; Excellence is being willing to be wrong.
Perfection is fear; Excellence is taking a risk
Perfection is anger and frustration; Excellence is powerful
Perfection is control; Excellence is spontaneous
Perfection is judgement; Excellence is accepting
Perfection is taking; Excellence is giving
Perfection is doubt; Excellence is confidence
Perfection is pressure; Excellence is natural
Perfection is the destination; Excellence is the journey
--author unknown
Here’s how I would summarize it's view of perfection:
"Perfection -- according to this rant -- is an obsession to be right, all while filled with fear, anger and frustration, driven by your inner control freak, under pressure to "take-no-prisoners" in route to some unworthy destination." -- Big Dreams.Com
My God! Stop the whining already.
These stark warnings -- all from recovering perfectionists -- parallel the common proclamation* that, “money is the root of all evil.” Yet, there is no inherent evil in money anymore than there’s evil in perfection.
Shakespeare warned that, “love of money” is at the root of all evil, not money itself. Likewise, it’s not perfection that is the “enemy of success,” but phycological enslavement to unwarranted perfection. It’s the attachment to money and the expectation of perfection that drives us to the dark side. Any fear of perfection itself is unfounded.
* In June 2010, Google had 675,000 references to Shakespeare's quote including, "love of money" compared with 2,000,000 without.
I offer that perfectionists dismiss excellent results because they have naively confused perfection with actual effects. It’s not having the goal of perfection that paralyzes their performance, but the illusion of achievability -- indeed the compulsion to actually achieve the ideal -- and the frustration that invariably follows.
Further, perfectionists hold a twisted sense of entitlement, where they feel cheated or unworthy if they don’t achieve perfection. They are, in effect, playing God. With such unattainable standards they often conclude, “why try?” This misperception, I believe, is the distinction between greatness and the "good enough" standard that fills the void once perfection is discarded.
It’s our divine right to align our being with perfection. Yet, we must then hold excellence in reverence, for it is as close as we can humanly get to the divine on this day.
A brush with perfection is a glimpse of the divine; momentary, unpredictable, and fleeting. A hole-in-one is a majestic experience but unrepeatable, and certainly not something we can expect on any given golf outing. The far more common outcome is an "excellent" drive, progressing our ball towards the pin. Humility accepts. Expectation rejects.
Pursue Perfection; Revere Excellence.
So, it is not the guiding beacon of perfection that must be rejected, but the expectation of a storied outcome. When we hold our successes -- and those of others -- with grace and humility, we are accepting that there is no deserving “perfection.” Rather, we must offer our very best expression of perfection on this day and fully accept the reality of our human limitations. Our goal then is to pursue perfection, yet revere excellence along the way.
Michael Jordan held an obvious reverence for excellence. He combined a legendary drive for perfection with humility, not frustration. He so aligned himself with perfection that he could close his eyes and make free throws. He knew he had perfected the fundamentals and used this exercise to test this belief.
Throughout, he never lost the joy of the game. With this attitude, he was undeterred by frequent setbacks -- "I have failed over, and over, and over again in my life.... and that is why I succeed" -- and became the greatest basketball player of all time.
Michael Jordan showed us that divinity can shine through us all.
Loren |
Post a Comment | 






